If I don't buy a takeaway have I saved money???

W3Schools

Jon

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
23,445
Likes
1,951
Points
283
Age
37
Location
Leeds
#1



I see this quite a bit on social media (mainly Instagram and the dreaded #debtfreecommunity) but I'm not so sure the math stacks up.


A person will put up an Instagram Story about how they've saved £20 by not getting a takeaway tonight.

Surely if they never spent the money in the first place they haven't SAVED anything, they just didn't spend any money.

However, if they bought a £40 takeaway and had a £20 off voucher code to use then they WOULD have saved £20..

What you guys in the TMS Brain Trust think???

 

The Reverend

The Reverend
Staff member
Joined
Oct 6, 2015
Messages
2,485
Likes
547
Points
313
Website
thereverend.co.uk
#2



I see this quite a bit on social media (mainly Instagram and the dreaded #debtfreecommunity) but I'm not so sure the math stacks up.


A person will put up an Instagram Story about how they've saved £20 by not getting a takeaway tonight.

Surely if they never spent the money in the first place they haven't SAVED anything, they just didn't spend any money.

However, if they bought a £40 takeaway and had a £20 off voucher code to use then they WOULD have saved £20..

What you guys in the TMS Brain Trust think???

I suppose its the same argument for taking your own pack lunch to work.

I could spend £10 a day on lunch OR I could save £7 by making my own lunch every day for £3.

I could spend £30 on a takeaway OR I could save £20 by getting the £10 meal deal from M&S.
 

Jon

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
23,445
Likes
1,951
Points
283
Age
37
Location
Leeds
#3
I suppose its the same argument for taking your own pack lunch to work.

I could spend £10 a day on lunch OR I could save £7 by making my own lunch every day for £3.

I could spend £30 on a takeaway OR I could save £20 by getting the £10 meal deal from M&S.
so it's a false economy then...
 

The Reverend

The Reverend
Staff member
Joined
Oct 6, 2015
Messages
2,485
Likes
547
Points
313
Website
thereverend.co.uk
#4
so it's a false economy then...
I depends.

I currently do spend £10 a day. By taking my own lunches I would save £7 a day.

Thats not a false economy. The only false economy would be someone who doesn't ever get takeaways saying that 'on friday I save £20 by not getting a takeaway'.

I suppose it comes down to whether you actual 'save' any money or it is just money you've not spent.

'I saved £100k not hiring a private jet to take me to magaluf and getting an easyjet flight instead.'
'I saved £100 by not eating at 'Dans Le Noir' and just eating my dinner with my eyes closed.'
 

Jon

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
23,445
Likes
1,951
Points
283
Age
37
Location
Leeds
#5
I depends.

I currently do spend £10 a day. By taking my own lunches I would save £7 a day.

Thats not a false economy. The only false economy would be someone who doesn't ever get takeaways saying that 'on friday I save £20 by not getting a takeaway'.

I suppose it comes down to whether you actual 'save' any money or it is just money you've not spent.

'I saved £100k not hiring a private jet to take me to magaluf and getting an easyjet flight instead.'
'I saved £100 by not eating at 'Dans Le Noir' and just eating my dinner with my eyes closed.'
Yeah see that's my point! The money was never going to be spent in the first place! That's like me looking at holidays online and closing the browser tab and then declaring I'VE SAVED MYSELF £4000 THIS YEAR ON HOLIDAY!! #NOSPENDDAYS
 

The Reverend

The Reverend
Staff member
Joined
Oct 6, 2015
Messages
2,485
Likes
547
Points
313
Website
thereverend.co.uk
#6
.... I'VE SAVED MYSELF £4000 THIS YEAR ON HOLIDAY!! #NOSPENDDAYS


Well done! You are an inspiration to us all! Can you add the story on Instagram so I can pin it to my Pintrest and do a reaction vlog on my Bebo?
 

Jon

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
23,445
Likes
1,951
Points
283
Age
37
Location
Leeds
#7


Well done! You are an inspiration to us all! Can you add the story on Instagram so I can pin it to my Pintrest and do a reaction vlog on my Bebo?
gah, the inspiration stuff does my nut in!!
Shout out to the_reverend_123 who is always inspiring me with their amazing 40p lunches
 

The Reverend

The Reverend
Staff member
Joined
Oct 6, 2015
Messages
2,485
Likes
547
Points
313
Website
thereverend.co.uk
#8
gah, the inspiration stuff does my nut in!!
Shout out to the_reverend_123 who is always inspiring me with their amazing 40p lunches
Yesterday I found some dust on top of a cupboard at work.

Zero Calories AND Zero Cost

#nospend #nofilter #inspiration #dust #anyone #no
 

gardenpea

Active Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2018
Messages
39
Likes
8
Points
38
#9
It's only money saved if you would genuinely normally have spent it (eg takeaway every Friday night) but you do have to offset the cost of what you've eaten instead.

Switching to own brand is a saving, but sticking with the same own brand you've always bought isn't.

That said, I do count my Shopmium cashback in the money I earn online as it usually replaces a purchase sooner or later.
 

TMSPRESTO

TotallyBlogging

Forum statistics

Threads
4,845
Messages
137,612
Members
7,099
Latest member
WilliamSlingsby

Latest profile posts

Planning to get in the Christmas spirit now - I've dug out the cards, wrapping paper etc
Jon
Have some Christmas cheer on TMS!
Jon
Spending money on yet more Xenforo license extensions for all you lucky people!!
LEGO Advent Calendar animation video 3 is now edited and I think it's my favourite so far! Eep!